Aug 31

2010

Why Did Google Ban Us from AdSense?

Posted by: Dan Fabulich | Comments (10)

This is the second blog post in a series of posts about Google AdSense. In the first post, I explained how Google has banned us from AdSense; in this second post, I’ll give our best guess as to why they banned us. We can’t know for sure–as we mentioned before, Google won’t tell us (or any other banned website) why they banned us, and we have never violated the AdSense rules or encouraged anyone to violate the AdSense rules.

While I was surprised that Google banned us, even though we have never violated Google’s Terms of Service, I was not surprised that they denied our appeal. Google’s policy is to ban suspicious websites, regardless of whether the site owners have personally broken the rules, and they would rather ban perfectly innocent websites than miss a single nefarious website.

We probably look suspicious in a few different ways:

1) We share our advertising revenue with our partner authors (all three of them). If you write a game in ChoiceScript, we offer to host it for you, and share the advertising revenue with you; authors get 75% of the revenue their games make.

Since we’re still in our first year, for now we only have four games and three partner authors on our site. But Google may have decided that our business model posed a risk to advertisers.

(This is especially unfortunate, because Google provides a special AdSense API allowing you to sign up individual authors with separate AdSense accounts and share the revenue, but it requires your website to have 100,000 daily page views first. We were almost there, before Google shut us down.)

2) Our website doesn’t look like an ordinary AdSense site. The AdSense product we were using is called “Google AdSense for Content,” but it might be more appropriate to call it “AdSense for Blogs.”

In “Google AdSense for Content,” Google crawls each web page on your site to decide which ads Google should display on that site. Ideally, Google would compute the perfect ad for every web page on the site, based on the words on that page.

This makes sense for blog posts, which rarely change very much once they’ve been published. But our online games aren’t really like that. Each time a player clicks the “Next” button, we turn to the next page of the story, which looks completely different from the previous page of the story.

Google may have noticed that our average user spends at least fifteen minutes on one page of our site, and thought: “Hey, that looks pretty suspicious.”

3) We encourage our users to support us — by sharing, not by clicking. At the end of each game, we invite users to support us by sharing our game with friends, using StumbleUpon, Twitter, or Facebook. We never wanted or expected our users to “support” us by clicking on our ads, but perhaps some people got the wrong idea.

(For the record, we have no idea whether anyone actually did give us supportive clicks. If you personally have clicked on our ads to support us, well, in hindsight, that probably didn’t really help us out very much, in the long run.)

4) I have multiple AdSense accounts. I (Dan Fabulich) have multiple Google AdSense accounts: one for Choice of Games and another for a separate business entity. Both of these accounts were shut down within 24 hours of one another. In fact, I don’t even know if they thought there was something suspicious about Choice of Games’s advertising activity–they may have thought there was something suspicious about my other site and banned Choice of Games because it was also one of my accounts.

Because, you see, when Google bans you, they don’t just ban your company. They ban YOU, as a human being. You’re not allowed to just turn around and form a new business entity with a new Employer Identification Number and re-join the AdSense program. (EINs are free in the United States.)

Since Google has banned me personally, there’s an entire business model I can never use again.

As you might expect, this upsets me personally; I’ll discuss my personal feelings on the matter in part 3.

10 Comments

  1. […] a lot more to say about this, but that’s plenty for now. In part 2, I’ll talk about why (we think) Google banned us from AdSense. Posted by Dan Fabulich on Tuesday, August 31, 2010, at 12:18 pm. Filed under Announcements, […]

  2. I’ve never “supportively clicked” on an ad for this website (I’ve only just found you!) but I probably have done elsewhere, under the misapprehension that if I looked at a few ads from a website I would be helping the website. No more ad clicking for me then!

    This is so desperately unfair. I can’t believe that you get a lifetime ban for something that isn’t your fault and where you’re not allowed to see the evidence. It’s a pity Google got so big. I used to like them.

    Will you go to a voluntary donation model? I know that I’m usually willling to chip in a dollar or two for a website I appreciate, especially if I can do it by PayPal.

  3. This is so much going in the vein of “fighting against piracy” and proposed solutions where people can get banned from internet usage or certain services if they are caught doing something illegal. In this case google is a private company, but with power comes responsibility, yes indeed.

  4. Glennye says:

    Firstly, I second fairyhedgehog’s proposal; I think a lot of users would be willing to donate at least SOMETHING to support a blog/site that they enjoy.
    Secondly, and perhaps most importantly, is there something we can do to support you by appealing to Google?

  5. […] first post, I explained how Google has banned us from AdSense; in the second post, I wrote about our best guess as to why they banned us. In this blog post, I discuss my personal feelings about this turn of […]

  6. Dan Fabulich says:

    Ironically, letters to support to Google will probably do more harm than good. They don’t want users who have supportive fans; they want websites that have wide appeal to the general public.

  7. Jason says:

    I would also voluntarily support the website with PayPal. I never even saw the Google ads here.

  8. Daniela says:

    pff is that really hard working?

  9. joe says:

    Are you looking for authors? I’ve been looking for something to do and have some programming knowledge, contact me @ the email i used to post this if you could use help. (can you access the email i submitted?) Actually screw all that just email me @ tikitime92@gmail.com if you have room for more authors.

  10. Just played choice of robot says:

    Listen guy im not gonna sugar coat it, i have no idea if any of what you wrote is true but i really dont care.I just played choice of robot and i can easily say it had the best story ive ever laid my eyes on, every decision was well written. When i messed up i felt regret and when i did well i felt proud. The only problem is that after playing it i no longer want to play games i usually am addicted to, everything else feels so inadequate. What ever happens dont stop making these games.

Leave a Response to Choice of Games Blog : We’re Banned from Google AdSense

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe by E-mail